Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by the Constitutional Court

2023-09-29 17:43:00, Politikë CNA

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

Activist Adriana Kalaja

Activist Adriana Kalaja has brought to attention the decision of the Constitutional Court in December 2022 for the vote of immigrants.

Kalaja claims that the Constitutional Court decision does not actually give immigrants the right to vote.

She states that the Constitutional Court did not fully accept the request of the "Diaspora for Free Albania" Association, but accepted it partially because of the bargains of Marsida Xhaferrlari, Enkelejd Alibeaj's wife, with the government.

Kalaja declares that the Court only accepted the request of the association "Diaspora for Free Albania", which is registered in Switzerland, and not that of the Albanian association "Organizata e Kendra".

According to her, in the decision of December 2022, only the point of violating the elections was accepted and not the one that gives the right to vote to immigrants.

Therefore, the activist emphasizes that this decision, in addition to being a constitutional coup and a dark stain in the entire history of this court, is also a dangerous precedent that legitimizes any foreign association to address the Constitutional Court, including criminal and anti-Albanian ones.

Full statement:

The decision on the vote of immigrants/diaspora, Constitutional PUÇ by the Constitutional Court...

First, I want to clarify that the problems that I will raise in this status are not related to personal persons, but to the moral and legal principles that I have followed all my life.

Secondly, I am aware that with this status, I will open many problems for myself and my clients, who have not received justice quite a few times, just because of my public position and the continued denunciation of the failure of the Justice Reform, but I have made a covenant only with the truth.

Thirdly, I look forward to the arguments and legal debate regarding this issue, which I think is very important, from lawyers and not only.

Fourthly, the fact that the promoters of this "victory" are called to every television counter of the government, and that the more I denounce it, the more I am declared "Non Grata" by them, proves that this decision was promoted and sponsored by the government.

Finally, the fact that for two years there has been no decision of this court against the party-state, legitimizes what I presented above.

Before analyzing this dark decision, I wanted to emphasize the fact that it is not true that this decision decided that the immigrants/diaspora should vote.

No.

This is one big lie and cacophony orchestrated by the regime, and it adds to the reasonable suspicion that it all serves itself.

The vote of immigrants/diaspora was and is sanctioned by articles 8 and 45 of the Constitution, the Electoral Code and article 5 of the Law "On Emigration".

What happened in the Constitutional Court at the end of 2022?

This court had for consideration two requests for the vote of immigrants/diaspora;

1. From the Association "Diaspora for Free Albania", registered in Switzerland and subject to Swiss law (hereinafter NPO 1).

2. From the Center "Organization of the Center", registered in the Court of the Judicial District of Tirana and subject to Albanian law (hereinafter NPO 2).

According to the decisions that I present below, the object of two requests is presented, the evidence marked in yellow 1/1 for NPO 1 and the evidence marked in pink 1/1 and 1/2 for NPO 2.

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

After the intervention of the government, the executor of the latter's bargains with AliBasha, Marsida Xhaferllari (in another status I will tell you why Xhaferllari is the executor of the power bargains with AliBasha), the court decided to partially accept the request of NPO 1 and not pass of the request in the plenary session of NPO 2 due to legitimacy.

To make the situation more understandable for all my followers and not only, I will divide this reasoning and legal argumentation as to why this decision is a constitutional coup in two groups:

I. In terms of formality (legitimacy):

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

Regarding this point, the court, contrary to the provision in article 46, 131 and 134 as well as the Law on Non-Profit Organizations, accepts the request of a foreign association (see evidence marked in yellow 1/6) and does not legitimize an Albanian association in this request (see evidence marked pink 2/7).

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

In addition to being a constitutional coup, this is also a stain of shame in the history of this court as long as foreign associations are not subject to Albanian law.

An accurate analysis regarding the legitimacy of NPO 1 was also given by the former President of this court, where she values ??as a primary condition the respect of Articles 46 and 134 of the Constitution (evidence marked with yellow 1/33).

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

II. In terms of the object (matter/matter):

Referuar provave të mëposhtme, nëse lexoni me kujdes provën e shënjuar me të verdhë 1/4, akti për të cilin është rrëzuar kërkesa e OJF 1 është akti administrativ 219/2021 i Ministrit të Shëndetësisë, i cili në këtë gjykim është paraqitur si shtesë objekti.

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

Pse po e theksoj këtë fakt?

Se OJF 1 në objektin e parë të kërkesës ka patur vetëm "Cënimin e të drejtës së votës në zgjedhjet e 25.04.2021" pa saktësuar në objekt si dhe qysh dhe, vetëm pas debatit në seancë plenare, ku dukshëm është konstatuar se kërkesa nuk ka objekt (pra nuk ka materie ose lëndë), kërkuesi shton objektin e padisë me këtë shkresë e cila:

1. Nuk është akt i juridikdionit kushtetues.

2. Është akt i juridiksionit administrativ.

3. Është "gjë e gjykuar" në kuptim të jurisprudensës, duke qënë se ky akt është çuar në Gjykatën Administrative nga ish Kryetarja e LSI, znj. Kryemadhi.

Por çfarë qëndrimi mban gjykata lidhur me këtë akt?

E rrëzon atë duke bërë dhe gafën e rëndë kushtetuese se pranon vetëm pikën e cënimit të zgjedhjeve, pikë e cila nuk mund të "mbahet në këmbë" nëse bie akti që e ka cënuar dhe e vërteton atë.

Lidhur me këtë pikë nj? analizë të plotë dhe shteruese kanë bërë dy gjyqtarët që kanë dalë në pakicë (shih provën e shënjuar me të verdhe 1/30).

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

Pra,

Gjykata Kushtetuese në shumicë:

1. Ka pranuar për shqyrtim kërkesën e një shoqate të huaj dhe që nuk është subjekt i së drejtës shqiptare.

2. Ka pranuar një pikë të objektit të padisë e cila kishte si akt justifikues të cënimit të së drejtës aktin që nuk u pranua për shqyrtim (ose u rrëzua).

Për këtë arsye them se ky vendim përveç se është puç kushtetues dhe një njollë e errët në gjithë historinë e kësaj gjykate, është njëkohësisht edhe precedent i rrezikshëm që legjitimon çdo shoqatë të huaj t'i drejtohet GJK, pëtfshirë edhe ato kriminale dhe antishqiptare.

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

Nga ana tjetër, çfare u fitua nga ky vendim ku, ashtu siç e përmënda më lart, vota e emigrantëve/diasporës është e garantuar me Kushtetutë?

Ndërkohë që përceç se objekti i kërkesës së OJF 2 është shumë e saktë dhe e bazuar në parimet dhe normat kushtetuese, në analizë të argumentave kjo OJF i kishte propozuar GJK zgjidhjen e votës së emigrantëge/diasporës (për këdo që është i interesuar jam e gatshme t'ja vë në dispozicion).

Unë si përfaqësuese e "Organizatës së Qendrës" po ndërmarr të gjithë hapat ligjorë për bllokimin e zbatimit të këtij vendimi antikushtetues që nga PDSH, Opozita e deri te Kuvendi.

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

Unë ju siguroj se do luftoj pa kompromis për shtetin ligjor t? së drejtës dhe që çështjet tona DUHET t'i zgjidhin gjykatat shqiptare dhe jo ato europiane, qe me gjasë do zgjidhë edhe këtë çështje antikushtetuese dhe kundër të Drejtave dhe Lirive të Njeriut të Garantuara me Kushtetututë.

Dhe unë, aq sa mundem.do ta mbroj me çdo kusht dhe ligjërisht Kushtetutën e vendit tim.

Plus që kam një ves të keq që gjerat e çoj deri në fund dhe ashtu si thonë Tironsit se:

Vesi del me shpirtin.

Adriana Kalaja: This is why the decision on the vote of immigrants is a coup by

PS 1: If someone feels offended or does not like what I state above, I invite him to a televised debate on the channel, day and time that he/she will choose, and while introducing me as a friend so that I don't "attack" him/her, he/she openly declares you secretly ask me that I am a mediocre lawyer and a pedantic lawyer. I expect him to tell me in his eyes.

PS 2: Given that this matter is of public interest, as well as the fact that I am blocked by most media and portals, please distribute them according to your desire and possibilities./ CNA