"The Guardian": The migrant deal will set a dangerous precedent in the EU

2024-10-11 18:42:00, Aktualitet CNA

"The Guardian": The migrant deal will set a dangerous precedent in the

Italy has officially opened two centers in Albania, where it plans to hold migrants crossing international waters as they try to cross from Africa to Europe.

The Italian ambassador to Albania, Fabrizio Bucci, said the centers were ready to accommodate people while their asylum requests were processed, but could not say when the first would arrive.

"As of today, the two centers are ready and functional," Bucci told reporters at the port of Shengjin on Albania's Adriatic coast, where the detainees will disembark.

Under the terms of a controversial deal that has been criticized by human rights groups but quietly approved by the EU, up to 3,000 migrants a month will be sent to centers while their asylum claims are processed in Italy. Children, women and vulnerable individuals will be sent to Italy.

The agreement was signed last November by the Italian Prime Minister, Giorgia Meloni, and her Albanian counterpart, Edi Rama.

Meloni said at the time that in exchange for Ram's support for the centers, she would do everything possible to support Albania's EU membership.

"The most useful element of this project is that it can represent an extraordinary deterrent for illegal migrants destined to reach Europe," Meloni said in June, adding that "the agreement can be replicated in many countries and become part of the structural structure of the EU. solution" to the migration crisis.

The two centers in Albania have cost Italy 670 million euros (564 million pounds). They are run by Italy and are under Italian jurisdiction. Albanian guards will provide external security.

A center has been established in Shengjin, about 45 miles (75 km) north of the capital, Tirana. The other is about 15 miles south of Shengjin near a former military airport in Gjadër.

Meloni has said officials will try to process asylum applications within 28 days, much faster than the months it currently takes in Italy.

Albania will only process applications from people from countries designated as safe by Italy, a list that was recently expanded from 15 countries to 21. The updated list includes Bangladesh, Egypt, Ivory Coast and Tunisia among others. A year ago, 56,588 people from these countries made their way to Italy.

The vast majority of applications are expected to be rejected because the countries the applicants come from are considered safe, which automatically limits the scope for granting asylum. Those whose applications are rejected will be detained before their eventual repatriation.

Anyone whose request is accepted will be taken to Italy.

Meloni and her right-wing allies have long called for European countries to share more of the burden of migration.

Aid workers have sharply criticized the deal, saying they fear the centers will quickly fill up with people waiting to return home.

Médecins Sans Frontières has said the agreement goes "a step beyond" previous agreements between EU countries and non-member states such as Turkey, Libya and Tunisia.

"The aim is no longer just to discourage departures, but to actively prevent people from fleeing and those rescued at sea to have safe and rapid access to European territory," MSF said in a statement.

Riccardo Magi, president of the left-wing party More Europe, said: "They are creating a kind of Italian Guantanamo, outside any international standards, outside the EU, without the possibility of monitoring the detention status of the people locked up in these centers. Italy cannot transport people rescued at sea to a country outside the EU as if they were packages or goods".

On August 14, the UN refugee agency, which has expressed serious concerns about the deal, agreed to monitor the first three months of the agreement's operation.

UNHCR said it was not a party to the agreement and held reservations about it, seeking clarification on how the agreement would be implemented. However, the agency said it had agreed to be a monitor to help "protect the rights and dignity of those subject to it".

Some Albanians have said the deal is a way of thanking Italy for taking in thousands of people fleeing poverty in Albania after the fall of communism in 1991.

The Council of Europe's human rights commissioner said the deal could set a dangerous precedent.

"The shifting of responsibility across borders by some states also encourages others to do the same, which risks creating a domino effect that could undermine the European and global system of international protection," he said./ CNA